Cancer is Not a Lifestyle

I’m not sure when I stopped being merely opinionated, and became a true curmudgeon. But I think it was about the same time that medical students started telling me that radiation oncology is one of the “lifestyle” specialties in medicine. According to the National Resident Matching Program, this year radiation oncology ranked 5th on the list of the most highly competitive residency programs, right after (and in order) dermatology, orthopedic surgery, otolaryngology, and plastic surgery. How, when and why did this arcane little specialty become so popular?

When I left internal medicine for a second residency in radiation oncology thirty years ago, we were thought of as the weird guys in the concrete shielded basement who spent all day pushing buttons to “zap” patients with evil rays which were just as likely to kill them as to cure them. When did this all change? When I was a resident in medicine, I knew that I wanted to take care of cancer patients. I had applied for, and been accepted at an excellent fellowship in hematology/oncology. During my senior medical residency, I realized that as a cancer doctor, I should know something about radiation therapy since it was one of the three modalities used to cure cancer, along with surgery and chemotherapy. There was no elective time in my upcoming fellowship, so I asked my Chief of Medicine if I could spend a month in the basement with the weird guys who pressed buttons. In medical school then, as now, no time had been relegated to teaching medical students about the therapeutic use of radiation. He said “yes”, and the rest, as they say, is history. Back in those days we had no good antinausea drugs, and we had no medications to boost a patient’s white count after a strong dose of chemotherapy. After receiving curative doses of chemotherapy for leukemias and lymphomas, patients would spend days if not weeks in laminar flow rooms, “hot and low”, meaning febrile and neutropenic, hoping that their bone marrow would recover before infections took their lives. We were curing cancer, but often at a terrible price. In that hospital basement, the early days of breast conservation therapy for early stage breast cancer were playing out before my eyes. Happy women who had been offered the choice of lumpectomy and radiation over mastectomy cheerfully bared their breasts in follow up clinic, exclaiming “Look at THESE!” I made the leap, and never looked back. Lifestyle had nothing to do with it.

So what do dermatology, orthopedic surgery, plastic surgery, ENT and radiation oncology have in common? In the first four, physicians who choose these specialties can virtually, if they choose, limit their practices to regular hours and high paying procedures where oftentimes they are paid cash for their services. Even though it would seem that orthopedic surgeons and plastic surgeons are amongst the first responders for the so-called “train wrecks” that are brought to the ER, in reality they can choose to do only the “elective” aspects of their fields, such as sports medicine and cosmetic surgery. And we all know what Botox and “fillers” have done for dermatology—they’ve practically put the plastic surgeons out of business! Radiation oncology has the advantage of regular hours (our patients are nearly always outpatients) and high reimbursement (our medical reimbursement system is based on how many procedures one performs, and the planning and delivery of radiation are considered procedures). And if you love computer games and movie special effects, effectively hitting your “target”, the cancer, while dodging the normal tissues, that radiation beam can become your personal “Avatar” in the war against an extremely formidable enemy.

But here’s the thing, kids. In dermatology and those other highly desired specialties, you get to “hit and run”. You don’t need to follow your patients long term, unless you want to. You help them, make them beautiful, cure their acne, fix their broken bones and tendons, give them new breasts, or eyelids, or noses, or even rear ends! You give them better hearing, or better breathing, or better speech. You make them young again; you make them run again. But if you want to cure cancer, it’s a whole different ballgame. Your patients may have side effects, difficult side effects, which you must manage on a daily basis for six to eight weeks. Your patients may have late effects, years after the radiation, just when they think that life is good again and they are home free. Your patients may actually die, either from their cancer, or from your treatment.

Think about that when you think about “lifestyle” specialties. If you can live with that, and maintain a cheerful countenance with a generous helping of compassion for the next thirty to forty years, then by all means, join me.

5 thoughts on “Cancer is Not a Lifestyle

  1. I admit I was scared ahead of time; I admit I said when I was young and ignorant, around the time you were in the basement, that I’d rather go on and die than take some of the treatments.

    Now, before I’ve even had a 6-month checkup, I take for granted that I had radiation.

    Today was going well until you got the the part about late side effects. Dang. I’d skillfully ignored that. . .

    • Margaret, I don’t think you have to worry. Our techniques have improved SO much that the risk of late effects now is MUCH lower than ever before. So much effort has gone into risk reduction (better imaging studies prior to treatment, better treatment planning and delivery systems, better target localization while ON treatment–all of these things have made therapeutic radiation for cancer safer than ever. There is no cancer treatment without any risks, sadly. But it bothers me when patients say, “Well my Aunt Tillie had radiation for cervix cancer in 1960 and she STILL has side effects!” as though we’ve made no progress at all. Just keep doing what you’re doing and let the doctors do the worrying. M

  2. ….So moral of this story is, if you can’t handle it and all that comes with being an Radiation Oncologist then don’t do the job? Would you recommend pursuing this job even though it can be stressful and heart breaking?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>